TL;DR
A study of 3.3 million students in grades 4–10 found that schools requiring phones to be locked away saw modest gains in math and reading scores from 2022 to 2026. The researchers equated those gains to one or two weeks of additional instruction per year, but the study does not settle how phone use outside school affects learning.
A study of 3.3 million U.S. students found that strict school phone bans were associated with modest improvements in math and reading scores, equivalent to roughly one or two weeks of additional instruction per year. The research, released Tuesday by academics at Harvard University and Dartmouth College with NWEA researchers, examines student outcomes through the 2025–26 school year.
Turn the school run and nap time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
The researchers analyzed MAP assessment results for students in grades 4–10 at 4,600 campuses, comparing schools that prohibited in-class phone use with otherwise similar schools that did not. In schools where students were required to put phones in lockable pouches, the study estimated cell phone activity fell by about 20%. The researchers said that measure may understate the change because phone-signal data can register devices that are on but not being used.
Average test-score gains were about 0.01 standard deviations, a small effect by common education-research measures; effects below 0.05 standard deviations are generally considered small. The authors translated the results into approximately two extra minutes of class time per hour, or one to two weeks of instruction across a school year. Scores generally shifted upward by similar amounts across demographic groups, with most differences between groups not statistically significant.
The study compares outcomes across schools rather than randomly assigning students to phone policies, so its findings show an association under the research design, not proof that bans alone caused every score change. The authors describe it as the first national study of in-school bans using student-level data and say it is the only study to track restrictive policies through the 2025–26 school year.
Small Gains Could Accumulate
The results matter because even limited annual gains could add up if they persist. The study’s lead author, Harvard economist Tom Kane, has described declining academic growth in the years before the pandemic as a “learning recession.” He argues that small improvements should be judged over time, rather than only by their effect in a single year.
For school leaders weighing restrictive policies, the findings offer evidence of a possible academic benefit, but not a large or settled one. The estimated gain is modest, and earlier research has produced mixed results. The study does not establish whether phone bans improve other outcomes, such as student well-being or classroom behavior, or whether the academic effects will grow with time.
Products Worth Considering

Dyson V9 Motorbar Cordless Vacuum

Philips Hue Festavia Permanent Outdoor String Lights, 80 Lights, 150 ft

Bose Smart Ultra Dolby Atmos Soundbar with Voice Control, HDMI eARC, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Evidence From Earlier Ban Studies
Phone restrictions have spread as schools and policymakers have debated how students’ devices affect attention and learning. This study focuses on policies that require phones to be put away during the school day, including use of sealed or lockable pouches, rather than every possible form of school technology restriction.
Earlier findings have varied. Stanford professor Thomas Dee helped conduct a national study circulated in the spring that found negligible academic effects and an increase in disciplinary incidents after bans began, with that rise fading over time. A 2025 study co-authored by RAND researcher Umut Ozek also found small learning improvements in the first years and an initial rise in behavioral problems. Ozek has said schools may need time to adjust before test-score benefits appear.
““One or two weeks is no big deal on a one-year basis, but what we should be looking for is small impacts on achievement growth that persist.””
— Tom Kane, Harvard economist and study co-author
Limits of the Evidence So Far
The reported gain is small, and the study cannot establish that the ban itself caused all of the difference. It also remains unclear whether results will persist or grow in later years, whether policies with less restrictive enforcement produce similar outcomes, and how much students continue using other devices during school.
Researchers also have limited evidence about students’ phone use outside school. Kane said that use remains a “black box,” while Dee raised it as one possible reason school-only restrictions may have limited effects. The source report says Kane sees a recent legal settlement with Meta as a possible way to study out-of-school use, but it does not provide details of a research plan or findings from that effort.
Researchers Seek Longer-Term Results
The next key test is whether the modest score gains continue as schools and students adapt to phone restrictions. The researchers’ analysis already extends through the 2025–26 school year, but the supplied report does not specify when a follow-up study will be released or whether the same schools will be tracked further.
Further research could also examine differences between enforcement approaches and account for phone and other device use beyond the school day. For now, school systems considering bans have evidence of a small academic association, alongside important unanswered questions about cause, duration and effects beyond test scores.
Key Questions
How much did learning improve in schools with strict phone bans?
The study found average gains of about 0.01 standard deviations in test scores, which the researchers equated to roughly one or two weeks of instruction per year.
How many students and schools were included?
The analysis covered 3.3 million students in grades 4–10 at 4,600 campuses, using math and reading results from NWEA’s MAP test.
Does the study prove that phone bans caused the gains?
No. Researchers compared schools with and without prohibitions, but this design does not prove that the bans alone caused the score differences.
Do phone bans affect behavior as well as test scores?
This study’s reported findings focus on academic outcomes and phone activity. Earlier studies cited in the report found increases in disciplinary incidents after restrictions began, though one study found that increase faded over time.
What remains unknown about students’ phone use?
Researchers say there is limited evidence about how much students use phones outside school and how that use relates to learning. It is also unclear whether the modest score gains will persist or increase.
Source: the74million.org
